| Top 20 2006 | ||
| 1 | Damaged Goods | Scrappy Jud Newcomb |
| 2 | Crashboombang | The Ginn Sisters |
| 3 | Waves | Sam Baker |
| 4 | Waiting | Ron Flynt |
| 5 | Wrong Foot | Michael Fracasso |
| 6 | I Don’t Feel That Way | Jon Dee Graham |
| 7 | By Eleven | Caitlin Cary |
| 8 | If I Needed Someone | Roger McGuinn |
| 9 | What’s So Funny About Peace, Love, & Understanding | Steve Earle |
| 10 | I Ain’t Got Nothin’ | The New York Dolls |
| 11 | Down to My Soul | Paul Kelly |
| 12 | Things We Said Today | The Beatles |
| 13 | Something Wonderful | Jon Dee Graham |
| 14 | Howlin’ Down the Cumberland | John Hiatt |
| 15 | Every Day I Have to Cry Some | Arthur Alexander |
| 16 | Fisherman | Leo Kottke |
| 17 | Soul of Constant Sorrow | Patty Loveless |
| 18 | Midnight Moonlight | Jerry Garcia Band |
| 19 | Lie To Myself | David Glaser |
| 20 | Still Got My Faith | Graham Parker |
| Top 21 2007 | ||
| 1 | Like A Wheel | Little Pink/Mary Battiata |
| 2 | Star Motel | Charlie Roth |
| 3 | Wrecking Ball | John Wort Hannam |
| 4 | 1962 | Michael Fracasso |
| 5 | I Knew It All | Bill Wence |
| 6 | Rocking Horse | Little Pink/Mary Battiata |
| 7 | You Tore Me Down | Sid Griffin |
| 8 | Old Rock And Roller | Bill Wence |
| 9 | The Rest Is History | Graham Parker |
| 10 | Read ’em ‘n’ Weep | Ian Hunter |
| 11 | You Won’t Talk About Love | Charlie Roth |
| 12 | Stolen Flowers | Little Pink/Mary Battiata |
| 13 | Cloudy Head | Cindy Woolf |
| 14 | Need You Now | Gurf Morlix |
| 15 | Soul of America | Ian Hunter |
| 16 | White Cross | Jeff Talmadge |
| 17 | Infantryman | John Wort Hannam |
| 18 | I Hate Christmas | Jon Dee Graham |
| 19 | You’re Just Drunk | Matt Harlan |
| 20 | because | Ron Flynt |
| 21 | Picasso’s Mom (live a cappella) | Paul Sanchez |
| Top 20 2008 | ||
| 1 | Always Tomorrow | Elizabeth Cook |
| 2 | Gonna Be | Elizabeth Cook |
| 3 | Goin Down De Ocean | David A. Alberding |
| 4 | Down Girl | Elizabeth Cook |
| 5 | Losing It | Elliott Murphy |
| 6 | Sometimes It Takes Balls to Be a Woman | Elizabeth Cook |
| 7 | The Mountain | Levon Helm |
| 8 | Longest Days | John Mellencamp |
| 9 | Wide River To Cross | Levon Helm |
| 10 | Let’s Take Some Drugs and Drive Around | The Silos |
| 11 | All Along the Watchtower | Tom Landa & the Paperboys |
| 12 | Fingerprints | Joe Grushecky |
| 13 | Pretty World | Sam Baker |
| 14 | The Rain Won’t Help You When It’s Over | Javier Escovedo |
| 15 | Carl Perkins’ Cadillac | Drive-By Truckers |
| 16 | Heart Breaks Like the Dawn | Chuck Prophet |
| 17 | Nothing But the Wheel | Peter Wolf |
| 18 | The Other Side Of The Reservoir | Graham Parker |
| 19 | The Last Star Of The Night | Elliott Murphy |
| 20 | I Will Not Let My Spirit Fall | Joe Grushecky |
| Top 20 2009 | ||
| 1 | Sunny Day | Mary Cutrufello |
| 2 | All Good Things | Jackson Browne |
| 3 | Rock and Roll | Jerry Lee Lewis |
| 4 | Run | Willie Nile |
| 5 | Lonesome Whistle | BettySoo |
| 6 | My Stunning Mystery Companion | Jackson Browne |
| 7 | American Rain | Mary Cutrufello |
| 8 | (I’ll Still) Love You Forever | Mary Cutrufello |
| 9 | God Bless This Mess | Sheryl Crow |
| 10 | Good Rock From Bad | Tim Carroll |
| 11 | The Midnight Rose | Willie Nile |
| 12 | Dreamers Walk Alone | Mary Cutrufello |
| 13 | Elizabethtown | Matt Harlan |
| 14 | Things We Said Today | The Beatles |
| 15 | I Still Believe In Love | Jon T Howard |
| 16 | House Of A Thousand Guitars | Willie Nile |
| 17 | Still Small Voice | BettySoo |
| 18 | Casey, Illinois | Bill Morrissey |
| 19 | Nothing To Lose | Effron White |
| 20 | Down To Faith | Byrd and Street |
| Top 21 2010 | ||
| 1 | Broken Things | K.C. Clifford |
| 2 | Broken | Dirk Hamilton |
| 3 | Songbird | K.C. Clifford |
| 4 | Another Million | Michael Fracasso |
| 5 | A Momentary Thing | Jaime Michaels |
| 6 | Freedom | Rex Foster |
| 7 | Working Class Hero | Michael Fracasso |
| 8 | Generous Friends | K.C. Clifford |
| 9 | Tore Up | John Lilly |
| 10 | Windmill Hills | Dirk Hamilton |
| 11 | Driving To Blissville (live) | Jeff Talmadge |
| 12 | Nothing To Lose | Effron White |
| 13 | Elizabethtown | Matt Harlan |
| 14 | One Spectacular Moon | Jaime Michaels |
| 15 | (I’ll Still) Love You Forever | Mary Cutrufello |
| 16 | Beautifully Broken | Jon Dee Graham & The Fighting Cocks |
| 17 | California Beach Boy | The Dollyrots |
| 18 | Still Small Voice | BettySoo |
| 19 | For No One | The Beatles |
| 20 | Aint That Just Like a Woman | Chuck Berry |
| 21 | A Soldier’s Christmas | Jeff Talmadge |
Jim Patton & Sherry Brokus 